About Natallie Liz

Natallie Liz, smiling in a pink blouse, with palm trees and ocean behind her.

Meet Natallie

I was born and raised here — third generation, Key West to Key Largo, back before the tourists found us. Before real estate, I spent 25 years teaching in Monroe County public schools, which means I've watched this community grow up, one classroom and one closing at a time.
That's really the difference. I'm not learning the Keys market as I go — I've lived it my whole life, and I know the people who make a transaction go smoothly: the lenders, the inspectors, the title and closing attorneys, the folks at Monroe County Building and Planning. Those relationships, some of them decades old, are what keep a deal on track when the Keys throw their usual curveballs — flood zones, ROGO, insurance timing, permits.
Whether you're buying your first place on the water, selling a home your family has held for years, or looking at an investment property from out of state, I'm here to walk you through it plainly and honestly, the way I'd want someone to walk my own family through it.

Natallie Liz

LICENSE NUMBER
3600038

Testimonials

Marcia D.

Marcia D.

From day 1 until the purchase of our new home in Key West, Natallie has been there with us every step of the way. Born and raised in Key West, Natallie was so familiar with all the important and most useful contacts. If we ever...
Read More
Simply Ecare

Simply Ecare

Natalie is an over the top realtor. She is fun, and easy to get along with. Even more important though, she listens to your needs and wants, does not send options that are not within your criteria, wasting time, is extremely qu...
Read More
Vicky D.

Vicky D.

Natallie is a true professional. Smart, thorough, thoughtful, and got the job done in a precarious market. We wish the new owners much happiness. Thank you, Natallie, Vickie
Read More
Chris H.

Chris H.

Natallie has sold multiple homes that I’ve been a part of the construction process on. As a life long local resident of the community she really knows the area & the market.
Read More
Cecilia N.

Cecilia N.

Natallie was very helpful and extremely professional throughout the process. She kept in contact with us every step of the way and made the sale of the property seamless.
Read More
Chip C.

Chip C.

Natalie was awesome! She was extremely responsive and got our real estate deal done quickly and efficiently…at our price. Highly recommend.
Read More
Diana & Mark S.

Diana & Mark S.

We were very happy to have Natallie as our realtor. She helped us find our dream home and guided us every step of the way, all the way to the keys in our hands. Natallie was incredibly thorough, knowledgeable, and went above an...
Read More
Seller

Seller

Natalie was a pleasure to work with start to finish. She went above and beyond to ensure we got the best price for our home. From the professional staging to the numerous open houses and events she made sure our home stood out ...
Read More
Island Welcome Real Estate

Buyer

Natalie did an outstanding job for our purchase of a new home. She was there to help through the entire process from the scheduled showing all the way through closing, she went above and beyond. Thank You Natalie!
Read More
Ruddy

Ruddy

Working with Natelli was a game-changer. Buying a home out of state can be daunting, but she made the entire process seamless. Natelli was more than just an agent—she was a true partner in this journey. From the first conversat...
Read More
Island Welcome Real Estate

Buyer

Natalie was AMAZING!! She always got back to us with any questions or concerns we had from beginning to closing. She showed us a few homes and was always kind and professional. We would highly recommend her!!
Read More
Island Welcome Real Estate

Buyer

Natallie's expertise in the real estate market, coupled with her genuine care for her clients' well-being, truly sets her apart as a top-notch professional in her field. I cannot recommend Natallie highly enough for anyone look...
Read More
Ann S.

Ann S.

From the moments we inquired about our home to the closing, Natalie was always there for us. Natalie is very friendly and knowledgeable answered all of our questions. Natalie was always available whether either through email or...
Read More

Browse My Past Sales

Work With Us

Discover the Florida Keys with a team that knows every sunset, shoreline, and neighborhood by heart. We’re more than real estate agents—we’re matchmakers, advocates, and lifelong partners in your journey. From dream homes to lasting friendships, we’re here to welcome you, guide you, and make paradise your home.

Follow Me on Instagram