Working Hard for YOUR Island Welcome Home

Serving All of the Florida Keys, Key West, Shark Key, Sugarloaf Key, Cudjoe Key, Summerland Key, Ramrod Key, Big Pine Key, Marathon, Islamorada, Key Largo

main

Meet Island Welcome Real Estate

Island Welcome Real Estate welcomes you and your hopes and dreams to the Florida Keys. We’re specialists in the Florida Keys real estate market, but we don’t just have unmatched insights into the housing landscape. We have an infectious enthusiasm for this palm-tree, sunset-filled, and sparkling-blue water paradise.

We’re matchmakers in this tropical haven, pairing you with your dream property and helping you integrate into our vibrant community. We greet your questions with our knowledge and patience, we support you beyond the transaction with our newly formed friendship, and we enrich your local lifestyle with our community mindfulness. We never miss an opportunity to welcome you into the neighborhood and be your infinite regional resource.

At Island Welcome Real Estate, we don’t just advocate for the good life. We also advocate for homeownership and property rights, and what better place to champion both than in the Florida Keys’ paradise. We’re committed to creating long-term relationships with you, assuring you of our unending support, and becoming the agents of choice for you and your friends and loved ones.

Featured Listings

View some of our most exclusive available listings.

For Sale

20 Shore

$899,000

20 Shore, Big Coppitt, FL 33040

2 BEDS
2 BATHS
1,513 Sq.Ft.

For Sale

1 Driftwood Terrace

$2,500,000

1 Driftwood Terrace, Key Haven, FL 33040

5 BEDS
3 BATHS
3,014 Sq.Ft.

Active Under Contract

31343 Ave I

$899,000

31343 Ave I, Big Pine Key, FL 33043

3 BEDS
2 BATHS
1,230 Sq.Ft.

For Sale

451 E Shore Drive

$2,995,000

451 E Shore Drive, Summerland Key, FL 33042

4 BEDS
3 BATHS
2,416 Sq.Ft.

Active Under Contract

23028 Sailfish Lane

$1,295,000

23028 Sailfish Lane, Cudjoe Key, FL 33042

3 BEDS
2 BATHS
1,360 Sq.Ft.

For Sale

1165 Lagoon Drive

$2,275,000

1165 Lagoon Drive, Summerland Key, FL 33042

3 BEDS
2 BATHS
2,156 Sq.Ft.

Highlights

18

Years of Experience

400+

Successful Sales

50+

Five Star Reviews

Meet Our Agents

Get to know our dedicated and talented team.

Tuttle

Sandra Tuttle

License #SL3093204

Realtor®

Pinholster

Taia Pinholster

License #SL3290623

Realtor®

Nardi

Maurizio Nardi

License #3391645

Realtor®

Farrell

Debra Farrell

License #SL3020493

Realtor®

Pingaro

Donnie Pingaro

License #1834648

Managing Broker

Ariel Murgado

Business Manager

Bledsoe

Ashley Bledsoe

Marketing Director

WHAT OUR CLIENTS SAY

Sandra was the most professional, skillful, knowledgeable, helpful agent we have ever met- 10 stars!

— Buyer | Seller

WHAT OUR CLIENTS SAY

Extremely professional experience with sandy with the human factor included! Right on with target numbers, comparisons and net provided. Lots of preparation for a 4 day listing and help with selection of best offer with advice for best and most secure offer. Would hire Sandy in a New York minute again!

— Buyer | Seller

WHAT OUR CLIENTS SAY

Could not recommend Sandra more highly! Excellence in every single aspect of our experience selling an expensive home after being on the market for a while, and with lesser representation. Sandra earned our future business with her acute insight and expert execution. She helped navigate through touchy situations honestly and with ease. She has a great personality, very friendly and accommodating even tho...

— Tamara Angel R.

WHAT OUR CLIENTS SAY

Sandra is thorough and professional. She is the very best and you won’t find better.

— Buyer | Seller

WHAT OUR CLIENTS SAY

Sandy is very experienced and knows how to maximize her clients satisfaction. Sandy was a dream to work with! Her attention to detail, knowledge and professionalism are sure to pay dividends for her clients and her long industrious career is proof of that. She will go the extra mile to satisfy all her clients needs. Is there anything she wont do? Thanks again Sandy, Your the best! We knew from our first ...

— Seller

WHAT OUR CLIENTS SAY

Sandy led us through the entire process with calm and reassuring knowledge. She took the time to make sure that we understood all that was happening and the reasons for each step. Sandy is totally professional and earned our highest recommendation. I would gladly hire her again for any real estate deal I might take part in. Initially, other agents I interviewed showed up with a generic recommendation for...

— Seller

WHAT OUR CLIENTS SAY

Like many others, we’ve dreamed of owning a property in the Florida Keys for quite some time. That dream has now become reality! We’ve bought many homes and dealt with many real estate agents, however, never have we experienced the level of expertise, local knowledge, and service which we experienced working with Sandy Tuttle. We wanted to know everything there was to know about the area from a residents...

— Nate B.

WHAT OUR CLIENTS SAY

We were purchasing a house sight unseen and Sandra really got what we were looking for and helped us find the perfect house. She was extremely responsive and was able to find houses that met both mine and my husband’s criteria.

— Buyer

WHAT OUR CLIENTS SAY

Holy moly!!! This lady went the extra mile for me again and again!!! Super easy to communicate with, great negotiator, superior local knowledge! I can’t believe how tirelessly sandy and her team worked to sell my home! Nothing was too much for her and she made an anxious time so much smoother! Talk to Tuttle!!!

— Seller

WHAT OUR CLIENTS SAY

I have both bought and sold with Sandy. She is an amazing Realtor®. She has a great work ethic. She is self motivated, has a great work ethic, she is honest and trustworthy. She has a real passion for the area and really enjoys helping people. The only issue I have is that she has set such a high standard, that I now compare other Realtors® to her, but they just don’t stack up.

— Buyer & Seller

Featured Communities

Explore more amazing communities!

Key West

Key West

Shark Key

Shark Key

Sugarloaf Key

Sugarloaf Key

Cudjoe Key

Cudjoe Key

Summerland Key

Summerland Key

Ramrod Key

Ramrod Key

Let’s Talk

You’ve got questions and we can’t wait to answer them.